Our office remains open to serve your important legal needs during these turbulent and challenging times. We are happy to schedule client consultations and client meetings by telephone or video-conference at your request.
Bryan E. Kuhn
Counselor at Law, P.C.
Business & Employment Law Attorney

Can Forcing an Employee to Use Technology Violate Their Religious Freedom?

On Behalf of | Dec 17, 2014 | Blog

In 2012, Consolidation Coal Company installed an attendance tracking system for payroll purposes at a mine in West Virginia. The system was a biometric hand scanner that creates and stores electronic information about an individual’s hand geometry for purposes of future identification. Mr. Butcher, an evangelical Christian, who had worked at the mine for thirty-five (35) years, stated that his religious beliefs prohibited him from submitting to the scanning and requested a religious accommodation. Mr. Butcher gave his manager a letter explaining his beliefs about the relationship between hand scanning technology and the Mark of the Beast. As discussed in the Book of Revelation, the Bible describes, “a beast that has authority on earth during end times and forces all people, to receive a mark on their right hands or on their foreheads.” (Rev. 13:16-17). Some Christians believe that technology will be used to implement the mark. Mr. Butcher proposed that the mine allow him to continue submitting his time and attendance manually as he had previously done, or that he be permitted to clock in and out with his supervisor.

Mr. Butcher’s manager responded to the request by handing Mr. Butcher a letter written by the scanner’s vendor discussing the vendor’s interpretation of the Book of Revelation and stating that the Bible only mentioned markings on the right hand. The letter concluded by assuring Mr. Butcher that the vendor’s scanner product does not, in fact, assign the Mark of the Beast. The managers proposed that Mr. Butcher submit to scanning his left hand turned palm up. Mr. Butcher refused stating that his beliefs prohibited him from scanning either hand. The company persisted stating that he would be subject to disciplinary action if he refused to scan his hand. Ultimately, Mr. Butcher chose to retire involuntarily rather than violate his beliefs.

After retiring, Mr. Butcher filed a Charge of Discrimination with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”). The EEOC filed a lawsuit on Mr. Butcher’s behalf alleging religious discrimination and failure to make religious accommodations. Title VII makes it unlawful to discriminate against any individual with respect to compensation, terms, conditions or privileges of employment because of such individual’s religion. Religion includes traditional, organized religions such as Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, and Buddhism, as well as, religious beliefs that are new, uncommon, not part of a formal church or sect, only subscribed to by a small number of people, or that seem illogical or unreasonable to others. The accommodation aspect falls under a discrimination claim where the employee seeks an adjustment to a neutral work rule as it infringes on the employee’s ability to practice his or her religion. The standard in religious accommodation cases is not whether the company officials agree with or share the employee’s religious beliefs, but whether the employer can provide an accommodation without incurring an undue hardship.

According to the EEOC, at least two (2) other mine employees were permitted exemptions from the scanning due to missing fingers and were allowed to submit their time and attendance by other means. Therefore, the mine is unlikely to be able to argue that allowing Mr. Butcher to submit his time by other means would cause an undue hardship. Mr. Butcher’s case is still pending in the Federal Court in West Virginia.

If you have a question regarding a religious accommodation in your workplace, contact us at www.BryanKuhnLaw.com/ to discuss your legal rights.

Column Image

“I used the Bryan E. Kuhn, Counselor at Law, P.C. team to help me with a case. They were always professional, upfront, and positive providing guidance while keeping me informed.”
– L.H.

“Everyone at the firm was professional, responsive and courteous. I would definitely recommend this firm if you are in need of superior legal assistance.”
– J.S.

“Bryan and his law firm operate with great professionalism and personal touch. I appreciated the way he and his team offered transparent communication.”
– N.S.

“The team was very professional in helping me to get through an uncomfortable ADA situation at my workplace. This was a very good legal experience. I would recommend Bryan E. Kuhn & team to anyone who needs work related legal help.”
– D.L.

“Bryan, Katie, and all the staff in this office are super fast to respond, expert in their fields, and always helpful. We have been extremely pleased with their services for our small business.”
– T.Z.

Column Image


Bg Subscribe
Contact Our Firm

Office Location

Bryan E. Kuhn, Counselor at Law, P.C.
1660 Lincoln Street Suite 2330
Denver, CO 80264

Local: 303-424-4286
Toll Free: 866-693-5541
Fax: 303-425-4013
Denver Law Office Map
FindLaw Network
Click for the BBB Business Review of this Attorneys & Lawyers - Employment Litigation in Denver CO