Business & Employment Law Attorney
866-693-5541 | 303-424-4286

UGG boot battle highlights design patent law

There are several well-known laws protecting Colorado entrepreneurs from intellectual property infringements. Common protections include copyright and trademark laws. However, two recent cases have highlighted a more obscure intellectual property protection: the design patent.

In July, Apple and Samsung finally settled a years-long battle over design patents for their smartphones. Meanwhile, Decker Outdoor Corporation, the maker of UGG boots, recently used design patent laws to sue Romeo & Juliette, a rival shoemaker that was accused of making UGG knockoffs.

One of the quirks of copyright law is that it dismisses the shape and silhouette of footwear and other fashion items. This makes it more difficult for companies to protect their designs. However, as U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in the Apple case, a design patent protects "new, original and ornamental" designs for a manufactured product that give it a "peculiar or distinctive appearance." Romeo & Juliette argued its boots were only similar to UGGs in the "obvious" ways that all boots are similar to each other. However, Decker was able to convince a jury that no previous boot designs, known as "prior art" in patent design cases, looked like UGGs until its design hit the market in the early 2000s. While Decker won this round, the fight is not over. R&J has filed an appeal before the 9th Circuit Court.

Intellectual property litigation can be complex and protracted. Companies with trademark issues or other legal concerns associated with growing a business could work with an intellectual property attorney to find effective solutions. The attorney could review the situation and develop strategies to protect a company's original designs from infringement.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  1. "I used the Bryan E. Kuhn, Counselor at Law, P.C. team to help me with a case. They were always professional, upfront, and positive providing guidance while keeping me informed."
    - L.H.

  2. "Everyone at the firm was professional, responsive and courteous. Kate was exceptionally knowledgeable and responsive and she helped me to achieve the desired outcome. I would definitely recommend this firm if you are in need of superior legal assistance."
    - J.S.

  3. "Bryan and his law firm operate with great professionalism and personal touch. I appreciated the way he and his team offered transparent communication."
    - N.S.

  4. "Kate & team were very professional in helping me to get through an uncomfortable ADA situation at my workplace. This was a very good legal experience. I would recommend Bryan E. Kuhn & team to anyone who needs work related legal help."
    - D.L.

  5. "Bryan, Katie, and all the staff in this office are super fast to respond, expert in their fields, and always helpful. We have been extremely pleased with their services for our small business."
    - T.Z.

  6. "Working with Bryan was amazing. His professionalism made a very stressful and difficult challenge as positive as possible. A great lawyer"
    D.K.